Mary Berry Buttermilk Pancakes Recipe – Thick, Fluffy & Golden

There’s something about Mary Berry Buttermilk Pancakes Recipe that just makes a lazy Saturday morning feel complete. These aren’t your everyday thin crepes they’re proper thick pancakes, wonderfully fluffy American-style breakfast stacks with golden edges, a light buttery flavour, and just the right amount of delicate sweetness from caster sugar and vanilla extract. The secret is the tangy buttermilk, which reacts with the bicarbonate of soda to create that signature airy texture preventing the flat heavy discs you get when the chemistry isn’t quite right. I remember the first time I made these on a Sunday with no real plan for the day, and they genuinely changed how I think about a sweet breakfast.

What makes this recipe stand out is how confidently it works for everyone from beginners tackling their first stack to anyone who just wants a reliable breakfast without the fuss. Whether you’re feeding the family on a relaxed brunch weekend or squeezing something special into busy mornings, this batter comes together in around 20 minutes to 25 minutes and delivers soft pancakes with a tender crumb and beautiful golden colour every time. The acidity of the buttermilk brings a tangy flavour that balances beautifully against the melted butter and creates that sweet balance you’d expect from classic pancakes. These American pancakes are truly the ultimate weekend breakfast.

Everything You Need — Ingredients at a Glance

Category	Ingredient	Quantity / Options	Notes
Dry Ingredients	Plain flour	250g plain flour	Standard quantity for the recipe
Dry Ingredients	Plain flour (alternative)	200g plain flour / 7oz plain flour	For slightly thinner pancakes
Dry Ingredients	Caster sugar	2 tablespoons caster sugar	Adds light sweetness
Dry Ingredients	Baking powder	2 teaspoons baking powder	Helps the pancakes rise
Dry Ingredients	Bicarbonate of soda	1 teaspoon bicarbonate of soda	Adds lift and softness
Dry Ingredients	Salt	1/2 teaspoon salt	Balances flavor
Wet Ingredients	Large eggs	2 large eggs	Main binding ingredient
Wet Ingredients	Buttermilk	500ml buttermilk	Standard liquid quantity
Wet Ingredients	Buttermilk (alternative)	350ml buttermilk / 12fl oz buttermilk	Creates a thicker batter
Wet Ingredients	Unsalted butter (melted)	50g unsalted butter melted	Adds richness and flavor
Wet Ingredients	Unsalted butter (alternatives)	45g unsalted butter / 1½ oz unsalted butter	Alternative measurements
Wet Ingredients	Vanilla extract	1 teaspoon vanilla extract	Adds sweetness and aroma
For Frying	Butter	As needed	Used for frying pancakes
For Frying	Vegetable oil	As needed	Alternative frying option
For Frying	Sunflower oil	As needed	Works well for frying
For Frying	Extra butter	As needed	Use between batches
Sweet Toppings	Maple syrup	To taste	Classic pancake topping
Sweet Toppings	Fresh berries	To taste	Adds freshness
Sweet Toppings	Icing sugar	To taste	Light sweet finish
Sweet Toppings	Sliced bananas	To taste	Soft and naturally sweet
Savory Toppings	Crispy bacon	To taste	Pairs well with syrup
Serving Notes	Buttermilk batter	—	Neutral flavor works with sweet or savory toppings
Serving Notes	Frying butter richness	—	Enhances flavor even without toppings

How to Make Mary Berry Buttermilk Pancakes Recipe

Start by combining your dry ingredients sift together the plain flour, caster sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda, and salt into a large mixing bowl. Sifting isn’t just for show; it genuinely helps remove clumps and creates a lighter batter from the start. Use a wire whisk to bring everything together for about 30 seconds, making sure the raising agents are evenly spread throughout the flour mixture. Meanwhile, in a separate jug, whisk eggs with the buttermilk, melted butter, and vanilla extract until you have a smooth mixture that’s fully blended with no yellow streaks remaining. When you combine batter by pouring the wet ingredients into the dry ingredients, stir gently the moment the white streaks disappear and the batter comes together, stop. A few small lumps are completely fine; do not overmix or over-beat, because that leads to tough pancakes rather than the fluffy pancakes you’re after. The batter should have a thick consistency nothing like a runny crêpe batter. Let it rest batter for 5 minutes so the raising agents activate and you get a noticeably lighter texture before the pan even touches the heat.

To prepare pan, place a heavy-based non-stick frying pan or flat griddle over medium heat on the hob and lightly grease with a knob of butter or splash of oil use kitchen paper to wipe it to a thin film of fat so the butter doesn’t burn. Once the pan is hot, spoon small ladles of batter roughly 2–3 tablespoons per pancake leaving enough space between pancakes so you don’t overcrowd pan. Let them cook pancakes on the first side for 2–3 minutes you’re waiting for bubbles rising to the surface, popping bubbles that bubbles stay open, and the edges begin to set until they look slightly matte and edges firm. That’s your signal. Using a thin turner or spatula, flip carefully and cook the second side for 60–90 seconds or 1–2 minutes — until golden brown and the pancakes feel springy to a gentle firmness check. Transfer each batch to a warm plate covered with a clean tea towel to keep warm while you work through the remaining batter. Serve immediately with your favourite toppings for the best pancake texture.

Recipe Tips Worth Knowing

One of the most genuinely useful things I’ve learned is how to make Homemade Buttermilk when you’ve run out. Simply pour 1 tablespoon lemon juice or white vinegar into 500ml milk 350ml milk works too for a smaller batch stir briefly and let it sit 10 minutes. It curdles slightly and that’s exactly what you want; it behaves just like the real thing in the batter. Another thing nobody talks about enough is the First Pancake Rule that first one is essentially a throwaway pancake that seasons pan and helps you gauge heat. If it burns, your heat too high; if it comes out pale and sad, your heat too low. Adjust and carry on. Always test heat with a tiny batter drop first if it sizzles and sets within seconds, you’re good to go. Also, letting the batter rest for 15 minutes allows the flour hydrate properly, the gluten relax, and the result is a noticeably fluffier pancake with better rise.

If you’re using self-raising flour for convenience instead of plain flour with 2 teaspoons baking powder, always check raising agents by checking tin dates — expired agents mean pancakes won’t rise and you’ll end up with heavy flat cakes and a dense texture. To keep pancakes warm while finishing the batch, place them in a single layer on a wire rack set over a baking tray in an oven at 100°C / 225°F / Gas Mark ¼ this keeps them warm without making them crisp pancakes. Using a jug for pouring gives far better batter control, producing neat round shapes with consistent portions that all cook at the same cooking speed. One rule I always follow: do not over-flip turn pancakes once only, waiting until you see proper air bubbles before touching them. If you want to prepare ahead, keep dry ingredients and wet ingredients in separate containers the night before, but never pre-mix them the bubbles go flat and overmixing batter develops gluten, giving you heavy pancakes. You can refrigerate batter for up to 12 hours with a gentle stir before using, but avoid high heat when cooking or the outside burns before the inside cook properly, leaving you with dark brown pancakes rather than the beautifully golden ones with that signature slight tang and extra soft texture this recipe is known for.

Ways to Serve These Pancakes

The most natural pairing for these is maple syrup with fresh blueberries or a handful of fresh berries tumbled over the top it’s simple, classic, and honestly hard to beat on a slow morning. Sliced bananas with chopped nuts add extra texture, while a spoonful of Greek yoghurt alongside raspberries keeps things a little lighter without losing any of the indulgence. For something more celebratory, go with whipped cream, strawberries, and a generous drizzle of honey with a sprinkle cinnamon these become proper indulgent pancakes that feel more like dessert than breakfast. I’ve also done a Nutella and banana stack that went down extremely well at a family filling brunch, and a squeeze lemon with dusting icing sugar version that tasted surprisingly elegant.

If you’re in the mood for something more substantial, crispy streaky bacon draped over a stack with maple syrup is the kind of sweet and savoury breakfast that converts people. A dollop Greek yogurt with a drizzle honey keeps it balanced if you want something less heavy. These pancakes also sit beautifully alongside Eggs, Baked Goods, and Bread for a fuller spread which makes them ideal brunch pancakes for feeding a crowd. Whether you lean into sweet toppings, fruity pancakes, or savoury fillings, the batter is neutral and sturdy enough to support whatever direction you take it. The classic pancakes lover will be happy with just butter and syrup; everyone else has a whole world of brunch serving ideas to explore.

Storing Your Buttermilk Pancakes

If you’ve made more than you can eat in one sitting which happens more often than you’d think leave them at Room Temperature only if they’re pancakes covered loosely with foil or a clean tea towel, and only for up to 4 hours. For anything longer, move them to the Refrigerator. Stack cooled pancakes in an airtight container or zip-lock bag and store in the fridge for up to 3 days. To reheat pancakes, a dry frying pan over low heat for a few minutes brings them back beautifully they come out with a slightly crispy edge that’s honestly even better than the original. A toaster works surprisingly well too, and the microwave on medium setting for about 20 seconds is the fastest option when you’re short on time, though you lose a little of that texture.

For longer pancake storage, Freeze them by stacking with layers separated by baking parchment or greaseproof paper, sealing in a freezer bag, and they’ll keep for up to 2 months. Wrap individual portions in clingfilm before bagging if you want to grab just one or two days worth at a time. Frozen pancakes go straight into the toaster for toaster reheating no thawing needed or use oven reheating at a low temperature for a larger batch. Refrigerating pancakes and freezing pancakes both work well with this recipe, and reheating pancakes is genuinely simple no matter which method you choose. One last tip — never store them in a stack without parchment or they’ll fuse together in the freezer and you’ll spend five minutes trying to separate them.

Nutritional Information

Each pancake from this recipe comes in at around Calories 210 kcal for a standard serving, though depending on the exact amounts used it can range from Calories 180 to as high as Calories 290kcal if you’re generous with the butter during frying. In terms of macros, expect around Carbohydrates 26g per pancake, or up to Carbohydrates 36g for larger portions the Total Carbohydrates 25g figure is a reasonable middle estimate for a standard-sized pancake. Protein sits at roughly Protein 6g, ranging between Protein 5g and Protein 9g depending on egg and buttermilk quantities. Fat comes in at approximately Fat 9g to Fat 12g, with a leaner version landing at Total Fat 6g and Saturated Fat ranging from Saturated Fat 3g to Saturated Fat 5g depending on how much butter goes into the batter and the pan.

On the micronutrient side, Sodium is notably higher in this recipe than a standard pancake typically between Sodium 200mg and Sodium 450mg per pancake, with a midpoint around Sodium 320mg due to the bicarbonate of soda and salt in the batter. Cholesterol is around Cholesterol 45mg, there’s a small Dietary Fiber 1g per serving, and Sugar ranges from Sugar 4g to Sugar 8g depending on toppings. All of these are estimated nutrition figures based on standard ingredients used and typical serving sizes the full batch makes roughly 8 pancakes, so adjust your calorie count accordingly. These are solid nutritional values for a weekend treat, and the pancake nutrition overall is reasonable especially if you keep toppings on the lighter side.

Step-by-Step Directions

Begin by taking a large bowl and using a wire whisk to whisk together the plain flour, caster sugar, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda, and salt until evenly combined. In a separate jug, crack in the eggs, pour in the buttermilk, add the melted butter and vanilla extract, and whisk until you have a smooth mixture with no streaks. Pour the wet mixture into the dry ingredients and gently stir until just combined remember, do not overmix. Heat a lightly greased non-stick frying pan or griddle over medium heat and once hot, spoon small ladles of batter into pan, spacing them apart. These pancake directions keep the whole process clear and straightforward from start to finish.

Wait until bubbles appear across the surface and the edges set before you flip carefully to the other side. Cook until golden brown underneath, then transfer to a warm plate and continue with the remaining batter. Serve warm with maple syrup, berries, or your favourite toppings whatever feels right that morning. The pancake cooking process is genuinely quick once the pan is up to temperature, and having everything prepped before you start makes it feel effortless. By the time the last pancake hits the plate, the first ones are still perfectly warm and ready to eat.

Notes & Cooking Tips

The single most important thing to carry away from this recipe is: do not overmix batter. Overmixing is the fastest route to dense pancakes, and it’s an easy mistake to make when you’re trying to get every lump out. A few small lumps in the batter are completely normal and actually a good sign they’ll sort themselves out during cooking. Always let the batter rest for at least 5 minutes before you start cooking; it makes a real difference and gives you noticeably fluffier pancakes with a better rise. These aren’t just pancake notes for beginners even experienced cooks benefit from slowing down at this stage.

Keep your cooked pancakes warm in a low oven while you finish the batch this is one of those small habits that completely changes how the meal comes together, especially if you’re cooking for more than two people. The pancakes stay soft, don’t dry out, and everyone gets to eat at the same time rather than in shifts. These cooking tips are genuinely the difference between a good stack and a great one, and once they become habit, the whole pancake texture improves without you having to change a single ingredient.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make these pancakes without buttermilk?

 Absolutely the simple substitute is to use regular milk instead of buttermilk. Just pour 1 tablespoon lemon juice or white vinegar into 500ml milk or 350ml milk, give it a quick stir, and let it stand 10 minutes or sit five minutes until it curdles slightly. It behaves exactly like real buttermilk in the batter and gives you the same tangy flavour and lift. This is one of those tricks that saves the morning when you realize mid-recipe that you’ve run out.

Can you freeze buttermilk pancakes?

 Yes let them cool completely first, then stack them with baking parchment between each one and seal them in a freezer bag. Freezing pancakes this way keeps them in good shape for up to 2 months. Reheat straight from frozen in a toaster or low oven and they come back surprisingly well without losing much texture.

Why is my pancake batter lumpy?

 A few lumps normal in buttermilk batter and are actually a good sign they mean you haven’t overworked it. The goal is soft pancakes, and the best way to get there is to avoid overmixing batter. Stop stirring the moment everything comes together, even if it doesn’t look perfectly smooth.

Can I add fruit or extras to the batter?

 Definitely blueberries and chocolate chips are both brilliant for extra flavour and extra texture. Add them to the batter before cooking by gently folding through the wet ingredients and dry ingredients after combining. Keep the folding light so you don’t knock the air out.

Why are my pancakes coming out flat?

 The most common cause is old baking powder that has lost potency always check the date on the tin before you start. The other culprit is over-mixing batter, which destroys the air bubbles that give the pancakes their rise. Both are classic pancake troubleshooting issues that are easy to fix once you know what to look for.

Why are my pancakes rubbery?

 This usually comes down to overmixed batter when you overwork the mixture, it develops too much gluten and the raising agents can’t react properly. Using a blender batter method is a particular offender here as it tends to overwork gluten far more than hand mixing. The result is rubbery pancakes with a dense, chewy texture rather than the light and fluffy ones you’re after.

How do I know when to flip?

 Wait until bubbles pop across the surface, the edges set firmly, and you can see dry edges forming around the outside of each pancake. That’s your reliable signal that the first side is done and the pancake is ready to flip cleanly without falling apart.

Most Related Posts

Mary Berry Simple Pancake Mixture Recipe

Mary Berry Marmalade Loaf Cake Recipe

Mary Berry Seville Orange Marmalade Recipe